Pediatric medical malpractice is statistically distinct from adult malpractice. According to a 10-year study by The Doctors Company, the nation’s largest physician-owned malpractice insurer, the leading allegation in pediatric claims is diagnostic error, accounting for over 30% of all claims against pediatricians.
Unlike general personal injury cases, pediatric claims involve unique physiological and legal complexities:
When a healthcare provider fails to adhere to the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) guidelines for diagnosis or treatment, and that failure results in injury, it is not merely a “complication”; it may be a breach of the standard of care.
A pediatric malpractice lawyer is experienced in legal cases where a child has been harmed by medical negligence. These attorneys have expertise in both the medical and legal standards that apply to pediatric care, and they are equipped to investigate, build, and litigate cases involving injuries to children caused by healthcare providers’ failure to meet the standard of care. It is advisable to seek a free consultation with our pediatric malpractice lawyers to discuss your case and legal options.
Key Takeaways
When a child suffers a catastrophic medical outcome, the immediate question is often whether the event was an unavoidable tragedy or the result of negligence. At The Killino Firm, our Team approaches this question with skepticism and a reliance on data. We focus on uncovering whether a poor outcome was preventable medical negligence or an unavoidable complication.
Pediatric medicine is statistically distinct from adult medicine. Children are not merely “small adults” in a physiological sense; they lack the ability to articulate symptoms, have different compensatory mechanisms for shock, and require precise, weight-based calculations for nearly every medication. Unlike adult patients, pediatric patients require unique standards of care and d medical attention, making pediatric malpractice cases particularly complex and demanding of expertise in child-specific medical protocols.
Data from the Physician Insurers Association of America (PIAA) indicates that while pediatricians face fewer medical malpractice cases and lawsuits overall compared to neurosurgeons or OBGYNs, the average indemnity payment in pediatric cases is significantly higher. Pediatricians are expected to provide reasonable care that meets accepted medical standards, and failure to do so can constitute malpractice. This reflects the reality that when errors occur in pediatric care, the long-term economic and quality-of-life damages are often profound.
Understanding why diagnostic errors are so prevalent in pediatric malpractice claims is essential for families evaluating their legal options, as explored in the following section.
Common examples of pediatric malpractice include misdiagnosis, surgical errors, and medication mistakes.
According to a study published in the journal Pediatrics, diagnostic errors account for the largest percentage of malpractice claims against pediatricians. An accurate diagnosis and timely intervention are critical in pediatric care, as a child’s pediatrician plays a vital role in identifying and treating a child’s condition to prevent long-term harm.
Unlike adult medicine, where surgical errors often lead the list of complaints, pediatric negligence is frequently an error of omission—a failure to act, a failure to test, or a failure to refer. Incorrect diagnosis and delayed diagnosis are common in pediatric malpractice cases, often because a pediatrician fails to recognize a child’s condition due to communication challenges unique to children. For example, appendicitis is frequently misdiagnosed in pediatric patients, especially in females, because symptoms may be atypical or difficult for the child to describe. When a pediatrician fails to provide a proper diagnosis or proper treatment, the pediatrician’s negligence may result in serious injury or long-term consequences for the child.
Bacterial meningitis remains one of the most litigated pediatric conditions. The symptoms—fever, lethargy, irritability—mimic common viral illnesses. However, the window for effective treatment is narrow. In addition to meningitis and appendicitis, conditions like pelvic inflammatory disease can also be misdiagnosed in female pediatric patients due to symptom overlap with other illnesses, such as urinary tract infections or appendicitis, leading to potential malpractice claims.
Appendicitis is the most common surgical emergency in children, yet it is missed at alarming rates in toddlers.
Surgical errors or negligence during these procedures can result in serious harm to a child’s body, including the risk of foreign objects being left behind or other complications, which may have long-term impacts on the child’s health and development.
While diagnostic errors are a leading cause of harm, medication errors also pose significant risks in pediatric care.
Administering medications in pediatric settings carries significant risks, as errors in ordering, transcription, dispensing, or administration can result in severe health consequences for children. All medical staff—including doctors, nurses, and pharmacists—play a critical role in preventing medication errors in pediatric care. Proper medication management is an essential part of medical care, and lapses can lead to serious, sometimes lifelong, harm. These dangers mirror broader national trends in medication error–related injuries and deaths seen across many healthcare settings.
The complexity arises because pediatric doses are calculated based on body weight (milligrams per kilogram) or body surface area.
Our Team at The Killino Firm frequently reviews Electronic Medical Records (EMRs) to verify that the weight entered into the system is current. Medical professionals—including doctors, nurses, and pharmacists—are responsible for ensuring accurate medication orders and proper administration. If a doctor prescribes medication based on a weight from a visit six months prior, the dosage will be incorrect. This can be a quantifiable deviation from the standard of care.
Beyond medication errors, the environment in which children receive care can also impact outcomes.
Parents often utilize Urgent Care centers or general Emergency Rooms rather than dedicated Pediatric ERs due to proximity. In these settings, not only doctors but also hospital staff, including nurses and support personnel, can be held liable if they fail to meet the appropriate standard of care when treating children in emergency situations.
A study published in Pediatrics demonstrated that mortality rates for critically ill children are lower in hospitals with high pediatric readiness scores.
If a child is taken to a “medical facility near me” that is not equipped for pediatric trauma, and the facility fails to transfer the child to a higher-level trauma center immediately, that delay can be actionable.
In addition to emergency care settings, newborns face unique risks such as kernicterus.
Kernicterus is a type of brain damage that is 100% preventable. It is caused by severe jaundice (high bilirubin levels) that goes untreated.
Bilirubin is a neurotoxin. If levels get too high, it crosses the blood-brain barrier and stain the brain tissue, this can cause cerebral palsy and hearing loss.
The American Academy of Pediatrics has published a specific nomogram (chart) that dictates exactly when a newborn needs phototherapy or a blood exchange transfusion based on their age in hours and bilirubin levels.
If a pediatrician discharges a newborn without checking bilirubin or ignores levels that fall into the “high risk” zone on the nomogram, they have ignored established medical guidelines.
The long-term consequences of pediatric malpractice can be devastating for families.
When assessing these cases, the focus is often on the “Life Care Plan.” Serious injuries resulting from pediatric malpractice can lead to significant damages, including the need for long-term care if the child suffers permanent injuries. The economic impact of a pediatric injury is distinct because the child may require care for 70 to 80 years. Medical malpractice lawsuits can help families recover compensation for these damages, addressing both immediate and lifelong needs. Many of these claims are handled by catastrophic injury lawyers who understand the complex medical, economic, and legal issues involved in severe child injury and wrongful death cases.
According to CDC data regarding Cerebral Palsy (CP):
The Team at The Killino Firm uses forensic economists to adjust these statistics for medical inflation, which has historically outpaced the Consumer Price Index (CPI).
Choosing the right pediatrician is important, but online searches can be misleading.
In the digital age, parents rely heavily on search engines to find care. However, search algorithms prioritize proximity and keyword density, not medical competency.
A study in JAMA Internal Medicine suggested that higher patient satisfaction scores do not necessarily correlate with better clinical safety outcomes. A doctor can have a 5-star rating for punctuality and friendliness yet still fail to adhere to AAP guidelines for sepsis screening.
The National Practitioner Data Bank (NPDB) restricts public access to detailed malpractice history. A parent searching online will rarely find information about prior settlements or diagnostic failures unless a state medical board has taken formal disciplinary action, which is rare.
Understanding the legal deadlines for filing a claim is essential.
The legal system acknowledges that a child cannot file a lawsuit on their own behalf. Therefore, some jurisdictions have specific “tolling” provisions for minors. Timely legal action is crucial in pediatric malpractice cases, as the statute of limitations determines how long you have to file a claim. Pediatric malpractice involves specific legal issues, such as extended statutes of limitations for minors, which may allow more time to pursue legal action.
While legal timelines for pediatric records are significantly longer than for adults, waiting to take action is a critical mistake from an investigative standpoint. A case that is viable today can quickly become “hollowed out” by time.
The Risk of the "Purged" Audit Trail
While hospitals must maintain the Legal Health Record (the final PDF or printout of a chart) for decades, the Audit Trail is far more fragile. This metadata is the “black box” of a medical malpractice case. It records every micro-action, such as:
As hospitals upgrade their Electronic Health Record (EHR) systems or migrate to new vendors, this granular metadata is frequently “flattened” or lost, leaving you with the final results but no evidence of the errors that led to them.
Record Retention vs. Data Integrity
Although most states require pediatric records to be kept until the patient reaches the age of majority (often 18 to 21 years plus the statute of limitations), this only applies to the basic medical record.
Memory Decay and Witness Drift
The nuanced human context behind a weight-based calculation is highly perishable, making early investigation essential for pediatric cases.
Birth injuries and birth defects are often confused, but they have distinct legal implications.
Informed consent in pediatrics is unique because it is actually “informed permission” granted by the parents, combined with “assent” from the child (if they are old enough).
Risk/Benefit Analysis
Navigating a pediatric malpractice claim requires legal expertise.
Navigating a pediatric medical malpractice claim can be complex and emotionally challenging. That’s why working with a law firm experienced in pediatric malpractice cases is essential. Consulting with our attorneys experienced in pediatric cases is essential to navigate the complexities of filing a claim. The Killino Firm brings together a team of skilled attorneys who understand the intricacies of medical malpractice claims, including the unique aspects of pediatric medical malpractice.
During a free consultation, the law firm will:
The legal team will handle every step of the process, including:
They will explain the potential outcomes of your pediatric medical malpractice claim and work tirelessly to secure the compensation your child deserves for:
By partnering with a law firm that is experienced in malpractice cases, you can focus on your child’s recovery while your legal team pursues justice on your behalf. Remember, most reputable firms (like The Killino Firm) offer a free initial consultation and work on a contingency fee basis, meaning you pay nothing unless your claim is successful.
To further clarify the legal and medical standards in pediatric malpractice, see the frequently asked questions below.
100% Secure & Confidential
Below are answers to common inquiries regarding the medical and legal standards applied to pediatric care. Pediatricians owe a professional duty to provide care that meets accepted medical standards. When a pediatrician’s negligence breaches this duty, it can result in serious consequences for children and their families, including significant financial and emotional impacts.
Children cannot advocate for themselves in court, so a parent or legal guardian must file a pediatric medical malpractice case on the child’s behalf.
In many states, a certificate of merit is required when filing a pediatric malpractice lawsuit. This document states that a qualified medical professional has reviewed the case and believes there is a valid basis for the claim.
Proving pediatric medical malpractice is a rigorous four-step legal process. To hold a healthcare provider accountable, our attorneys must establish the four essential elements of negligence: Duty, Breach, Causation, and Damages.
Our legal team must first show that a formal provider-patient relationship existed. In pediatrics, this means the healthcare provider had a legal obligation to provide the child with the standard of care that a reasonably prudent professional in the same field would provide under similar circumstances.
Once duty is established, our lawyers must prove the provider “breached” it. This is typically done through expert testimony from other pediatricians or specialists. They must demonstrate that the provider’s actions—such as a misplaced decimal in a weight-based dose—fell below the accepted medical standard.
Establishing that a mistake occurred is not enough; the lawyer must prove that the breach was the direct cause of the child’s injury. This is often the most contested phase of a case. The attorney must show that the harm was not a result of the child’s underlying illness, but specifically a result of the provider’s error.
Finally, our lawyers must document the actual harm or “damages” suffered by the child and the family. In pediatric cases, this often includes:
Families may seek compensation for a variety of losses in pediatric malpractice and personal injury cases, including:
In wrongful death cases arising from pediatric malpractice, families may be entitled to recover economic losses (such as medical bills and funeral expenses).
Additionally, depending on the laws of your state, you may be entitled to non-economic damages, which can include compensation for the child’s conscious pain and suffering prior to death, as well as the parents’ loss of companionship, love, and affection.
The standard of care is not written in a single book. It is defined as what a reasonably prudent pediatrician would have done under similar circumstances. This is established through expert testimony.
Yes. Under HIPAA, parents have the right to their child’s medical records. However, the “audit trail” (the digital footprint showing who accessed the file) can require a specific legal request or subpoena, which our Team handles during the discovery process.
A pre-existing condition does not absolve a doctor of negligence. If a child with asthma dies of pneumonia because the doctor failed to treat the infection, the asthma is a “comorbidity,” not an excuse. The doctor must treat the patient they have, including their vulnerabilities.
It is a common misconception that Urgent Care centers are held to a “lower” legal standard than Emergency Rooms. While their equipment may differ, their legal obligations do not.
The Uniform Standard of Care: Every physician, whether in a hospital or a neighborhood clinic, is held to the same Standard of Care: they must act as a reasonably prudent provider would under similar circumstances. In a pediatric context, this means that an Urgent Care provider has the same duty as an ER doctor to recognize “red flag” symptoms. If a child presents with signs of meningitis or respiratory distress, the provider’s failure to identify those symptoms is a breach of the standard of care, regardless of the building’s name.
The Duty to Stabilize and Transfer: While an Urgent Care is not equipped for surgery, they are legally required to be equipped for triage.
In the eyes of the law, “we didn’t have the right equipment” is not a defense if the provider failed to recognize that the equipment was needed in the first place or promptly triage and transfer to a facility with the equipment.
If a child suffers a permanent brain injury, they may never be able to work. Forensic economists project what that child would have earned over a lifetime based on statistical averages and parental education levels. This is a standard component of damages in pediatric law.
A resident is a doctor in training. A fellow has completed residency and is training in a sub-niche (like Pediatric Neurology). Errors often occur when residents are left unsupervised. We investigate the level of supervision present at the time of the injury.
Yes. Pharmacists have a “duty to warn” and a duty to catch obvious dosing errors. If a doctor writes a prescription for a 10x overdose, a competent pharmacist should flag it. If they fill it, both the doctor and the pharmacist may share liability.
If a nurse or medical assistant administers the wrong vaccine or mishandles a patient, the employing pediatrician or the medical group is typically liable for that employee’s negligence under the doctrine of respondeat superior.
This requires a review of the records against the medical literature. If the outcome (e.g., ruptured appendix, hearing loss from meningitis) is a known complication of delayed treatment, and the records show a delay occurred, the injury may have been preventable.
If your child has suffered an injury due to medical negligence, taking prompt action is important. Pediatric malpractice claims are subject to specific legal deadlines, and early investigation can make a significant difference in the outcome of your case. By understanding the basics of medical malpractice and working with our dedicated law firm, you can ensure your child’s rights are protected and that your family receives the support and compensation needed for recovery.
The Killino Firm is committed to advocating for children and families affected by pediatric medical malpractice. Our experienced catastrophic injury lawyers offer a free initial consultation to discuss your case, answer your questions, and outline your legal options. We understand the challenges families face after a serious injury and are here to help you navigate the legal process with compassion and expertise. Don’t wait—contact a pediatric malpractice lawyer today to take the first step toward justice and a brighter future for your child.
Disclaimer: This content provides general information and statistical data. It is not legal advice. Medical standards evolve, and individual case outcomes vary.
K
Keri S
7 months ago
T
Trisha H
7 months ago
C
Courtney S
7 months ago
R
Rhonda L
7 months ago
M
Michaelene C
7 months ago
C
Corey E
7 months ago
J
Jeanne Y
7 months ago
R
Reggie B
7 months ago
Catastrophic child and birth injuries can shatter the lives of not just the babies and children, but also their families. Families are left to navigate a complex maze of medical challenges, financial burdens, and emotional turmoil. But, this is where Jeffrey Killino and his team of dedicated lawyers can provide the support and guidance families need most.
For over 2 decades, Jeffrey Killino and his team have secured life-changing results for babies and children facing catastrophic injuries. Our clients gain access to the best medical care, financial security, and peace of mind, knowing their futures are protected.
Jeffrey Killino and his team of child and birth injury lawyers are committed to go beyond securing multi-million dollar settlements and verdicts. We measure our success by our positive impact on our clients’ lives. We’re dedicated to supporting them throughout their journey, even after their case is resolved.
Jeffrey Killino and his team of child and birth injury lawyers are committed to more than just securing multi-million dollar settlements and verdicts. We measure our success by our positive impact on our clients’ lives, helping them access the best medical care, achieve financial security, and find peace of mind. We also actively work to prevent injuries and promote safety for everyone.
Text With Us
We'll text you!
"*" indicates required fields
By submitting, you agree to be contacted about your request & other information using automated technology. Message frequency varies. Msg & data rates may apply. Text STOP to cancel. Privacy Policy
Call Me
We'll call you!
"*" indicates required fields
By submitting, you agree to be contacted about your request & other information using automated technology. Message frequency varies. Msg & data rates may apply. Text STOP to cancel. Privacy Policy
Book A Consultation
We're ready to answer your questions!
Email Us
We're available by email!
"*" indicates required fields
By submitting, you agree to be contacted about your request & other information using automated technology. Message frequency varies. Msg & data rates may apply. Text STOP to cancel. Privacy Policy
Text With Us
We'll text you!
"*" indicates required fields
By submitting, you agree to be contacted about your request & other information using automated technology. Message frequency varies. Msg & data rates may apply. Text STOP to cancel. Privacy Policy
Call Me
We'll call you!
"*" indicates required fields
By submitting, you agree to be contacted about your request & other information using automated technology. Message frequency varies. Msg & data rates may apply. Text STOP to cancel. Privacy Policy
